When you buy through links on our site, we may earn a commission (info)

Pit boss vs Traeger

Pit Boss vs Traeger – Which Grill Is Better?

Wood pellet grills have become the ultimate choice for grillers. And when it comes to that, Traeger and Pit Boss are the best brands to give you what you need.

To know what extra vibe their pellet grills hold, read our Pit Boss vs. Traeger review below. 

Best Overall Pit Boss
440D
Best Overall Traeger
Ironwood 650
PIT BOSS 72440-PB440D LGrill 440 Deluxe Wood Pellet Grill, Square inches, Stainless Steel
Traeger Grills Ironwood 650 Wood Pellet Grill and Smoker with Alexa and WiFIRE Smart Home Technology - Black
This medium-height grill is suitable for those who detest the tall ones in the market. With all the convenience it offers, all you need to do is master grilling to make the most out of it.
If you are looking for compact pellet grill with sufficient cooking space, this unit is for you. You can smoke meat and vegetables to perfection without a problem.
Best Overall Pit Boss
440D
PIT BOSS 72440-PB440D LGrill 440 Deluxe Wood Pellet Grill, Square inches, Stainless Steel
This medium-height grill is suitable for those who detest the tall ones in the market. With all the convenience it offers, all you need to do is master grilling to make the most out of it.
Best Overall Traeger
Ironwood 650
Traeger Grills Ironwood 650 Wood Pellet Grill and Smoker with Alexa and WiFIRE Smart Home Technology - Black
If you are looking for compact pellet grill with sufficient cooking space, this unit is for you. You can smoke meat and vegetables to perfection without a problem.

Table of Contents

Pit Boss vs Traeger Pellet Grills: Which One Should You Buy?

Here are the incredible features of Traeger and Pit Boss grills that will make you fall for them instantly.

traeger and pit boss pellet grills advantages

Pit Boss Advantages

  • Highly affordable pellet grills
  • More storage space all around, adjustable and retractable
  • Includes P setting in most units
  • Heavy-gauge stainless steel construction
  • Comes with a 5-year warranty
Traeger vs Camp Chef traeger and pit boss pellet grills

Traeger Advantages

  • Precision cooking with Turbo Temp, Direct D2 Drive, and AGL
  • Remote operation (Alexa-enabled)
  • 6-in-1 cooking versatility
  • Easy to use and assemble

Best Overall: Pit Boss 440D vs. Traeger Ironwood 650

Pit Boss 440D Pellet Grill

Our overall choice from Pit Boss is the 440D model because of its highly affordable price and durable construction. This grill will not only avoid rust but also provide you with a max temperature of 500°F. It also comes with a smoker, flame broiler (for direct grilling), and even a built-in temperature gauge on the lid that goes up to 750°F. 

With two-tier cooking grates and 465 square inches of cooking space, you can cook a variety of foods in one go. The only concern with this grill is its sudden temperature spike and auger system, but it’s nothing that a pro cannot handle. 

Pros:

  • Durable and built to last long
  • Reaches up to 500°F and above
  • Tools hooks and stainless-steel shelf
  • Sizable cooking surface area
  • Automatic start and cool down
  • Two-toned black-and-copper finish
  • Affordable

Cons:

  • Poor customer service

Pit Boss 440D is one of those versatile pellet grills that lets you sear and smoke instead of grilling alone. It has a well-built grease management system and comes with a bottle opener, ample storage space, and an automatic ignition system.

Traeger Ironwood 650 Grill

This elegantly built Traeger grill had us fall for it in the first glance. Be it the WiFIRE Technology, 6-in-1 cooking versatility, sturdy all-terrain wheels, or digital control panel – Ironwood 650 has left us impressed throughout. 

Ironwood 650 boasts of 650 square inches of cooking space that can easily cook eight chickens at a time, making it perfect for backyard parties. Its stainless-steel construction means that you may not have to invest on other pellet grills ever again.

Pros:

  • Sufficient cooking surface
  • Storage space on both sides of the unit
  • Rollerblade wheels
  • Supports TurboTemp, D2 Direct Drive, and Alexa
  • Efficient temperature control
  • No need for charcoal and gas
  • Easy to assemble and operate

Cons:

  • Expensive

The 20-lb pellet hopper (and its sensor), meat probe, TurboTemp (immediately reaches desired set temperature), D2 Direct Drive (eliminates auger jam issues), and the LED digital panel can add extra stars to this Traeger grill. 

Best Budget: Pit Boss Sportsman 820 vs. Traeger Renegade Pro

Best Budget Pit Boss
Sportsman 820
Best Budget Traeger
Renegade Pro
PIT BOSS 10537 PB0820SP Wood Pellet Grill, Black
Traeger Grills TFB38TOD Renegade Pro Pellet Grill and Smoke 380 Sq. in. Cooking Capacity, Black/Orange
The aesthetics of this grill will instantly capture you. Moreover, it is easy to assemble, handle, and control temperature range.
Though it is the most affordable of all Traeger grills, it is packed with a lot of features. You will be able to cook food perfectly using this unit because of its stable temperature control.
Best Budget Pit Boss
Sportsman 820
PIT BOSS 10537 PB0820SP Wood Pellet Grill, Black
The aesthetics of this grill will instantly capture you. Moreover, it is easy to assemble, handle, and control temperature range.
Best Budget Traeger
Renegade Pro
Traeger Grills TFB38TOD Renegade Pro Pellet Grill and Smoke 380 Sq. in. Cooking Capacity, Black/Orange
Though it is the most affordable of all Traeger grills, it is packed with a lot of features. You will be able to cook food perfectly using this unit because of its stable temperature control.

Pit Boss Sportsman 820 Pellet Grill

The looks, the larger cooking surface area (849 square inches) and pellet hopper capacity (21 lbs), and the extra storage space all provide an upper hand to Pit Boss Sportsman 820.  What it lacks in some advanced technological features for precision cooking has been made up for by its dial-in digital control with P setting. 

Pros:

  • Great finish with orange highlights
  • Tracks fuel with pellet hopper window
  • Monitor meat doneness and supports P setting
  • Easy to use and assemble
  • Stainless steel removable and adjustable side rack

Cons:

  • No extra handle or wheels

Sportsman 820 has Pit Boss’s patented flame broiler, which can be easily adjusted with a bar leveler. It also has ample storage space on the right, left, and bottom areas, as well as a bottle opener, spice rack, tool hooks, and many more. 

Traeger Renegade Pro Series Pellet Grill/Smoker

Traeger Renegade Pro is a budget-friendly grill that you can get your hands on easily. This is a perfect grill for small-sized families that love having BBQ parties on weekends. 

Since it has 380 square inches of cooking space, it will serve you a fantastic quantity of grilled food. 

Pros:

  • Steel construction with durable coating
  • Side rack and smokestack
  • Two sturdy rollerblade wheels
  • Bucket for collecting ash
  • Cool-touch handle
  • Comes with a 3-year warranty

Cons:

  • Temperature control dial

This Pro series grill has an impressive 18-lb pellet hopper capacity, which is compatible with the cooking area. Even at such a low price, you can experience 6-in-1 versatility and durability, enjoy operating digital temperature control, and facilitate precision cooking with Advanced Grilling Logic.

Best for Beginners: Pit Boss Sportsman PB206PSP2 vs. Traeger Pro 780

Best Pit Boss for Beginners
Sportsman PB206PSP2
Best Traeger for Beginners
Pro 780
PIT BOSS 10538 PB206PSP2 Wood Pellet Grill, Black
Traeger Grills Pro Series 780 Wood Pellet Grill and Smoker with Alexa and WiFIRE Smart Home Technology - Bronze
This mini grill manages to have two-tier cooking grates and 18-lb pellet hopper. You can take it on your next vacation and ditch your luggage bag with no regrets.
This is a great minimalistic grill with no extra fuss. It includes every possible technology that the brand offers for precision cooking, along with a grilling guide.
Best Pit Boss for Beginners
Sportsman PB206PSP2
PIT BOSS 10538 PB206PSP2 Wood Pellet Grill, Black
This mini grill manages to have two-tier cooking grates and 18-lb pellet hopper. You can take it on your next vacation and ditch your luggage bag with no regrets.
Best Traeger for Beginners
Pro 780
Traeger Grills Pro Series 780 Wood Pellet Grill and Smoker with Alexa and WiFIRE Smart Home Technology - Bronze
This is a great minimalistic grill with no extra fuss. It includes every possible technology that the brand offers for precision cooking, along with a grilling guide.

Pit Boss Sportsman PB206PSP2 Portable Grill

The Sportsman portable grill is ideal for beginners and travelers alike. You will be amazed by its flexibility, considering its foldable legs can turn it into a rolling griller in no time. More importantly, this unit doesn’t take much power to operate and can even be connected to your car inverter.

Pros:

  • Premium gauge stainless steel construction
  • 19-lb pellet capacity
  • Includes one meat probe
  • Grease management system
  • Fan forced convection cooking, smoker
  • Flame broiler adjustable bar at the front
  • Facilitates direct as well as indirect grilling

Cons:

  • Gets hotter on one side

Sportsman has a pellet hopper at the back and grill grates in the front half. Its 387 square inches of cooking area will allow you to feed a few people easily. 

When it comes to temperature range, you don’t have to worry about that either. This grill has a dial-in digital control with an LED display. It also has stainless-steel latches, so it’s effortless to secure the lid. 

Traeger Pro 780 Grill

Loaded with advanced features, Traeger Pro 780 grill is perfect for beginners. It has 780 square inches of cooking space and four wheels, so you can move it around even when the grill is working. The 18-lb pellet hopper, barrel-shaped chamber, and two-tier chamber system will enable you to cook for hours with ease. 

Pros:

  • Easy ash cleanout system
  • All-terrain wheels with lock latches
  • Alexa-enabled
  • Heavy-grade stainless-steel body
  • Bronze-colored chamber lid
  • Comes 1500 inbuilt recipes with grill guide

Cons:

  • Expensive

Traeger Pro 780’s advanced digital temperature controller with an LED display lets you cook delicious foods even without expertise. The Pro series D2 Controller, D2 Direct Drive, TurboTemp, and WiFIRE technology are all flushed in it, proving that it is perfect for beginners.

You get precision cooking, improved searing marks, Set It and Forget It feature, and grill-cum-oven this Pro series grill. It’s as easy to operate as a microwave oven, with an added benefit of using the unit as a smoker. 

Best for Pros: Pit Boss Rancher XL vs. Traeger Ranger

This minimalistic grill is for someone looking for a large cooking space at the cheapest price possible and isn’t too obsessed with advanced technology. 

You can gift it to anyone because it’s so reasonably priced and compact. Thanks to the griddle, it can be used to cook anything you like, including fried eggs and pancakes.

Pit Boss Rancher XL Pellet Grill

Rancher XL is a big Pit Boss unit that can definitely be used in competitions and commercial spaces or if you love to throw big parties. Just cook on it once, and it can feed an impressive of people because of its surface area that goes beyond 1000 square inches. When you fill the pellet hopper, it will run for hours without interruption. 

Pros:

  • Enormous cooking space
  • Heavy-duty build
  • Porcelain-coated cooking grates
  • Fan-forced convection cooking
  • Maximum temperature up to 500°F
  • 31-lb hopper capacity
  • Ash management system

Cons:

  • Auger jam issues

With ample storage space on all sides, tool hooks, and a bottle opener, a pro may have more fun cooking over it. The analog thermometer over the chamber lid also adds to its aesthetic appeal and functionality. 

The grill features the traditional V3 digital control board that only comes with a dial and LED readout. Still, it has an impressive hopper capacity of 31 lbs, 8-in-1 cooking versatility, pellet fuel window, and even a standard flame broiler.

If you like Pit Boss grills, you might be interested in reading this review to ease the decision-making process.

Traeger Ranger TBT18KLD Pellet Grill

Traeger’s Ranger is a portable pellet grill that can be loaded in the back of your vehicle without a hassle. Its shape is similar to those traditionally styled suitcases we used to carry.  If you are a professional RV traveler or adventurer and excels in grilling, this is undoubtedly made for you. 

Pros:

  • Heavy and durable build
  • Comes with meat probe and griddle
  • Digital controller with LED readout
  • Four legs for stability
  • Stainless-steel lid latches
  • Priced below $400

Cons:

  • Poor grease management issues

Its griddle can be used for sautéing fish and veggies or making an omelet. It also has a special digital controller, Advanced Grilling Logic, Keep Warm feature, and many more. 

With 8 lbs of hopper capacity, 187 square inches of cooking space, lid latches, and even cook timer, it fits for everyone, even if you’re pros, beginners, travelers, or just normal people.

Final Verdict

The Pit Boss pellet grills included in our list stands tough against the Traeger pellet grills. It’s difficult to do that since the latter come with ultimate precision cooking and have been the pioneers of wood pellet grills. Still, the new Pit Boss Sportsman series has totally outdone the others with their advanced digital control board with P setting. It provides a flame broiler, advanced temperature range control, and more storage space than Traeger at a much lesser price. 

However, if you are looking for long term and durable grills with at least a 3-year warranty, Traeger’s grills won’t disappoint anytime. Still, if you are on a budget, these best grills under 500 need your attention.

To summarize this Pit Boss vs Traeger review, both brands flaunt amazing grills that are all worth trying. Also, don’t forget to check out our comparison of Camp Chef vs. Traeger and Camp Chef vs. Pit Boss.

FAQs

1. What is P setting in Pit Boss pellet grills?

P in P setting stands for Pause. This can be used to maintain the temperature when your pellet grill is either too hot or too cold. With the P setting’s help, you can increase or decrease the pause time between pellet cycles. If your grill is too hot, you can withhold the pellets in the auger to lower the temperature, resulting in more smoke. 

Moreover, did you know that pressing the P button for long can change the temperature readings from Fahrenheit to Celsius and vice versa? 

2. Are wood pellet grills worth the money?

Yes, they are worth the money as they provide more cooking versatility. Moreover, they do not cost too high — you can even find wood pellet grills for even less than $500. Though they require electricity to operate, the power used is minimal and will not be too heavy for your pocket. 

3. Is Pit Boss better than Traeger?

There is no clear winner between Pit Boss and Traeger pellet grills. Some of the Pit Boss grills work much better than Traeger, while others are not. It all depends on your requirements and the amount of money you are willing to spend. 

Though Traeger and Pit Boss pellet grills are highly affordable, the latter miss out on advanced features that can enhance the user’s grilling experience. Also, Traeger grills provide the most impressive tailgater lineup. Nevertheless, Pit Boss offers a 5-year warranty, while Traeger only gives a 3-year warranty.  

4. Are pellet grills good for health?

Pellet grills are safer to use health-wise compared to other types. When it comes to risks, it all depends on how well you operate and take precautions. Hence, choose between Traeger and Pit Boss accordingly.

Similarly, you might also like to read our Z grills review.

5. How long do Traeger grills last?

As Traeger provides a 3-year warranty on some of its wood pellet grills, they meant to last that long or more. Their durability also depends on how well you clean and maintain the unit. Still, just by looking at the Traeger grills, you should be able to feel their sturdiness.

Noam

This article is written by Noam Shahar the founder of Limited-Red, Noam is a serious carnivore, And he has a strong passion when it comes to meat and cook, He Decided to review the "BBQ world" 9 years ago after discovering how many people struggle with choosing their dream grill.
Noam

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.